From Truth, Beauty, Freedom, and Books
She asks: How far can a modern novel "reference" a classic before it becomes derivative? What are some books you think were successful or unsuccessful at referencing or using classic literature? OK, to answer her question.
While I did like Jane Austen Book Club, I don't like rewritten stories, generally, ever. But if we have to do it, it can be done well. Bridget Jones' Diary for instance covered her references to Pride and Prejuidice well. I don't care at all for things like P&P&Zombies. There's too much leaning on Austen there, for my comfort. I'd rather see the author write something original.
Thursday, March 11, 2010
Home »
authors
,
memes
,
writing
» How far can a modern novel "reference" a classic before it becomes derivative?






































2 comments:
Thanks for taking the time to answer the question on your blog!
I have the same problem with a lot of adaptations, especially Jane Austen ones. Sometimes you wonder why the author had to use Austen's characters to write the book--why not just come up with their own characters? Is it laziness or marketing or both?
I wish I could answer that, too! Thanks for reading. I sure appreciate it!
Post a Comment